Brown Wrestling All-Americans and Ivy/EIWA Champions
| NCAA All-Americans | ||
| Name | Year | Place |
| J. Dana Eastham | 1953 | Fourth |
| Willie Carpenter | 1996 | Sixth |
| Tivon Abel | 1998 | Fifth |
| Ophir Bernstein | 2014 | Eighth |
| EIWA Champions | |
| Name | Year |
| Bob Hill | 1987, 1988 |
| Steve Thoma | 1992* |
| Sepp Dobler | 1992 |
| Joe Mocco | 1992 |
| Jim Pedro | 1993 |
| Paul Collier | 1994 |
| Mike Francesca | 1996 |
| Willie Carpenter | 1997^ |
| Tivon Abel | 1997*, 1998 |
| Livio DeRubbo | 2000 |
| Dave Foxen | 2012 |
| * Named EIWA Championship Outstanding Wrestler | |
| ^ Earned Fletcher and Sheridan Awards at EIWA Championships | |
