Rookie of the Year
| Name | Sport | League | Year |
| Steve Daniels | Baseball | Ivy League | 2006 |
| Ravi Malick | Baseball | Ivy League | 1993 |
| Damon Huffman | M. Basketball | Ivy League | 2004-05 |
| Mike Waitkus | M. Basketball | Ivy League | 1982-83 |
| Carlos Williams | M. Basketball | Ivy League | 1989-90 |
| Sean McGonagill | M. Basketball | Ivy League | 2010-11 |
| Desmond Cambridge | M. Basketball | Ivy League | 2017-18 |
| Maia Baker | W. Basketball | Ivy League | 1988-89 |
| Margaret Fuchs | W. Basketball | Ivy League | 1987-88 |
| Sarah Hayes | W. Basketball | Ivy League | 2002-03 |
| Martina Jerant | W. Basketball | Ivy League | 1991-92 |
| Shayna Mehta | W. Basketball | Ivy League | 2015-16 |
| Michelle Pagliaro | W. Basketball | Ivy League | 1990-91 |
| Kate Veronneau | W. Basketball | Ivy League | 1996-97 |
| Shelly Weaver | W. Basketball | Ivy League | 1989-90 |
| Donna Yaffe | W. Basketball | Ivy League | 1981-82 |
| Nick Andrade | M. Fencing | NFC | 2019-20 |
| Umar Masood | M. Fencing | NFC | 2015-16 |
| Clarissa Allen | W. Fencing | NFC | 2014-15 |
| Signe Golash | W. Fencing | NFC | 2017-18 |
| Cara Gardner | Field Hockey | Ivy League | 1999 |
| Christine Monteiro | Field Hockey | Ivy League | 1989 |
| Chas Gessner | Football | Ivy League | 1999 |
| Sean Morey | Football | Ivy League | 1995 |
| Steve Morgan | Football | Ivy League | 2004 |
| Brittany Park | W. Golf | Ivy League | 2018 |
| Beth Boisvert | Gymnastics | ECAC | 1996-97 |
| Jessica Buck | Gymnastics | ECAC | 1998-99 |
| Caroline Morant | Gymnastics | ECAC | 2013-14 |
| Alicia Sacramone | Gymnastics | ECAC | 2006-07 |
| Geoff Finch | M. Ice Hockey | ECAC | 1990-91 |
| Brian Ihnacak | M. Ice Hockey | ECAC | 2003-04 |
| Dan Allen | M. Ice Hockey | Ivy League | 1983-84 |
| Jimmy Andersson | M. Ice Hockey | Ivy League | 1994-95 |
| Geoff Finch | M. Ice Hockey | Ivy League | 1990-91 |
| Brian Ihnacak | M. Ice Hockey | Ivy League | 2003-04 |
| Ryan Mulhern | M. Ice Hockey | Ivy League | 1992-93 |
| Michael Ross | M. Ice Hockey | Ivy League | 1989-90 |
| Tara Mounsey | W. Ice Hockey | ECAC | 1996-97 |
| Tara Mounsey | W. Ice Hockey | Ivy League | 1996-97 |
| David Evans | M. Lacrosse | Ivy League | 1993 |
| Tom Gagnon | M. Lacrosse | Ivy League | 1983 |
| Darren Lowe | M. Lacrosse | Ivy League | 1989 |
| Greg Rozycki | M. Lacrosse | Ivy League | 1992 |
| Lauren Becker | W. Lacrosse | Ivy League | 1984 |
| Amanda Hatton | W. Lacrosse | Ivy League | 1996 |
| Scott Geppert | M. Soccer | Ivy League | 2005 |
| Paul Grandstrand | M. Soccer | Ivy League | 2007 |
| Jack Hagstrom | M. Soccer | Ivy League | 2015 |
| Suzanne Bailey | W. Soccer | Ivy League | 1987 |
| Theresa Hirschauer | W. Soccer | Ivy League | 1985 |
| Lynn Marinello | W. Soccer | Ivy League | 1983 |
| Kathryn Moos | W. Soccer | Ivy League | 2003 |
| Brittany Raphino | W. Soccer | Ivy League | 2019 |
| Rebecca Rosen | W. Soccer | Ivy League | 2018 |
| Bekah Splaine | W. Soccer | Ivy League | 1998 |
| Lisa Gawlak | Softball | Ivy League | 1986 |
| Courtney Jenkins | Softball | Ivy League | 2004 |
| Christy Trexler | Softball | Ivy League | 1990 |
| Allen Post | M. Squash | Ivy League | 1993-94 |
| Brandon Burke | M. Tennis | Ivy League | 2011 |
| Jamie Cerretani | M. Tennis | Ivy League | 2001 |
| Bianca Aboubakare | W. Tennis | Ivy League | 2008 |
| Alyza Benotto | W. Tennis | Ivy League | 2015 |
| Dayna Lord | W. Tennis | Ivy League | 2014 |
| Aimee Bower | Volleyball | Ivy League | 1988 |
| Sophia Miller | Volleyball | Ivy League | 2019 |
| Corre Myer | Volleyball | Ivy League | 1998 |
| Tomo Nakanishi | Volleyball | Ivy League | 1996 |
| Cole Atwell | M. Water Polo | NWPC | 2019 |
| Toby Espinosa | M. Water Polo | CWPA (North) | 2008 |
| Henry Fox | M. Water Polo | CWPA (North) | 2011 |
| Kate Woods | W. Water Polo | CWPA (South) | 2011 |
| Willie Carpenter | Wrestling | Ivy League | 1992-93 |
| Bronson Lingamfelter | Wrestling | Ivy League | 1998-99 |
| E.C. Muelhaupt | Wrestling | Ivy League | 1985-86 |
