First-Year Male Athlete Award
Initiated in 1991 and presented to the outstanding first-year male athlete.Â
| Name | Sport | Year |
| Geoff Finch | Ice Hockey | 1991 |
| Dave Gustovich | Wrestling | 1992 |
| Willie Carpenter | Wrestling | 1993 |
| Marquis Jessie | Football | 1994 |
| Dana Quick | Soccer | 1994 |
| Jimmy Andersson | Ice Hockey | 1995 |
| Sean Morey | Football | 1996 |
| Trinity Gray | Track | 1997 |
| Marcio | Soccer | 1998 |
| Bronson Lingamfelter | Wrestling | 1999 |
| Chas Gessner | Football | 2000 |
| Matt Kutler | Baseball | 2001 |
| Jason Forte | Basketball | 2002 |
| Ibrahim Diane | Soccer | 2003 |
| Eric Thomas | Tennis | 2004 |
| Jeff Schell | Wrestling | 2005 |
| Basu Ratnam | Tennis | 2006 |
| Dan Rosen | Ice Hockey | 2007 |
| Paul Grandstrand | Soccer | 2008 |
| Graham Tyler | Baseball | 2009 |
| Svetozar Stefanovic | Water Polo | 2010 |
| Sean McGonagill | Basketball | 2011 |
| Ophir Bernstein | Wrestling | 2012 |
| Cedric Kuakumensah | Basketball | 2013 |
| Dylan Molloy | Lacrosse | 2014 |
| Zachery Emrich | Track & Field | 2015 |
| Jack Hagstrom | Soccer | 2016 |
| Phil Goss | Lacrosse | 2017 |
| Desmond Cambridge | Basketball | 2018 |
| Tristan Crozier | Ice Hockey | 2019 |
