Arlene Gorton '52 Cup
Presented to the female varsity athlete who most consistently displays the ideals of sportsmanship and fair play. It is named in honor of former Brown Associate Director of Athletics Arlene Gorton ’52 in recognition of her role in developing women's intercollegiate athletics at Brown.
| Name | Sport | Year |
| Nancy Fuld | Tennis | 1976 |
| Sandy McDougall | Tennis | 1977 |
| Laurie Raymond | Ice Hockey | 1978 |
| Adrienne Morphy | Squash/Tennis | 1979 |
| Linda Stratton | Basketball | 1980 |
| Darcy Fernald | Soccer | 1981 |
| Pam Heggie | Swimming | 1982 |
| Callie LaMay | Softball/Field Hockey | 1983 |
| Sue Maloney | Basketball | 1984 |
| Mardie Corcoran | Ice Hockey/Softball | 1985 |
| Katelyn King | Swimming | 1986 |
| Kelley Shanahan | Field Hockey | 1987 |
| Maria Rabb | Crew | 1988 |
| Teri Smith | Track | 1989 |
| Torri Connell | Crew | 1990 |
| Susan Smith | Track | 1991 |
| Jen Hunter | Track | 1992 |
| Tracy Cisek | Swimming | 1993 |
| Shannon Bryant | Ice Hockey | 1994 |
| Cathy Luke | Volleyball | 1995 |
| Kjersten Boschen | Basketball | 1996 |
| Michelle Kupka | Tennis | 1997 |
| Phoebe Koch | Lacrosse | 1998 |
| Tania Belisle-Leclerc | Swimming | 1999 |
| Elise Roy | Soccer/Lacrosse | 2000 |
| Christina Sorbara | Ice Hockey | 2001 |
| Dawn Chuck | Swimming | 2002 |
| Sarah Gervais | Soccer | 2003 |
| Jeanie Ward-Waller | Water Polo | 2004 |
| Jamie Johnson | Soccer/Skiing | 2005 |
| Christine Livoti | Fencing | 2006 |
| Jessica Kondrick | Volleyball | 2007 |
| Sarah Wu | Crew | 2008 |
| Aleksandra "Ola" Mackiewicz | Fencing | 2009 |
| Thelma Breezeatl | Track & Field | 2010 |
| Katie Gannett | Soccer | 2011 |
| Aileen Daniels | Basketball | 2012 |
| Kelley Harrison | Field Hockey | 2013 |
| Alison Mullin | Soccer | 2014 |
| Janet Leung | Softball | 2015 |
| Isabel Runge | Crew | 2016 |
| Sarah Lucenti | Volleyball | 2017 |
| Anya Barca-Hall | Gymnastics | 2018 |
| Meghan Wimmer | Softball | 2019 |
