Men's Lacrosse All-Americans
| Name | Team | Year |
| Bill Aliber | 1982 | |
| Bill Aliber | First Team | 1983 |
| Richard Alter | First Team | 1966 |
| Bob Anthony | 1969, 1970 | |
| George Armiger | First Team | 1966 |
| George Armiger | 1967 | |
| Tad Barrows | 1979, 1980 | |
| Gerry Batty | 1968 | |
| Kylor Bellistri | Honorable Mention | 2016 |
| Henry Blynn | Honorable Mention | 2016 |
| Kevin Braney | 1995 | |
| Rick Buck | 1970 | |
| Jordan Burke | 2008 | |
| Jordan Burke | First Team | 2009 |
| Brendan Caputo | Honorable Mention | 2016 |
| Bill Carey | 1976 | |
| William Carr | 1966 | |
| Greg Cattrano | 1996 | |
| Greg Cattrano | First Team | 1997 |
| Jed DeWick | 1997, 1998 | |
| Tom Draper | 1964 | |
| Chris Eustis | 1965 | |
| David Evans | First Team | 1994, 1995 |
| David Evans | 1996 | |
| Mike Evans | 1976 | |
| Peter Fallon | 2009, 2011 | |
| Mark Farnham | 1979, 1980 | |
| Pat Flynn | 1991 | |
| Tom Gagnon | 1984, 1985, 1986 | |
| Mike Gannon | 1991 | |
| Chas Gessner | 2002 | |
| Phil Goss | Honorable Mention | 2018 |
| Phil Goss | Honorable Mention | 2019 |
| Will Gural | Second Team | 2016 |
| Rob Gutheil | 1994 | |
| Jeff Hacker | 1980, 1981 | |
| Rick Handelman | 1980 | |
| Mike Healy | 1964 | |
| Steve Heffernan | 1985 | |
| Jeff Iserson | 1994 | |
| Bill Kavan | 1971, 1972 | |
| Jack Kelly | Honorable Mention | 2015 |
| Jack Kelly | First Team | 2016 |
| Larken Kemp | Second Team | 2015 |
| Larken Kemp | First Team | 2016 |
| Larken Kemp | Second Team | 2017 |
| Bill Lemire | 1964 | |
| Mike Levin | 2002, 2004 | |
| Angelo Lobosco | 1980 | |
| Scott Lohan | 1985 | |
| Darren Lowe | 1990, 1991 | |
| Darren Lowe | First Team | 1992 |
| Bob MacLeod | 1975, 1976 | |
| Oliver Marti | 1992, 1993 | |
| Mick Matthews | 1985 | |
| Bill McComas | 1987 | |
| Bill McComas | First Team | 1988 |
| Jay McMahon | 1989, 1990 | |
| Jay McMahon | First Team | 1991 |
| John Meister | 1979 | |
| Dylan Molloy | Third Team | 2015 |
| Dylan Molloy | First Team | 2016 |
| Dylan Molloy | Second Team | 2017 |
| Jimmy Mormile | 2002 | |
| Bob Mueller | 1973, 1974, 1975 | |
| Thomas Muldoon | 2009, 2010 | |
| Darren Muller | 1984, 1985, 1986 | |
| Jamie Munro | 1989 | |
| Bill Ohlsen | 1977, 1978 | |
| Reed Overby | 1987 | |
| Greg Rozycki | 1994, 1995 | |
| Stephan Russo | 1973 | |
| Bob Scalise | 1970, 1971 | |
| Rupert Scofield | 1971 | |
| Harvey Smith | 1993 | |
| Jay Stalfort | 1993, 1994 | |
| Dom Starsia | 1973, 1974 | |
| Tom Stranko | 1967 | |
| Chris Sullivan | 2000, 2001 | |
| Dennis Sullivan | 1996 | |
| Jon Thompson | 2003 | |
| Andy Towers | 1990 | |
| Andy Towers | First Team | 1991, 1993 |
| Tom Towers | 1988 | |
| Carter Trudel | 1992 | |
| Alec Tulett | Second Team | 2016 |
| Alec Tulett | Honorable Mention | 2017 |
| Rich Tuohey | 1990 | |
| John Yozzo-Scaperrotta | Honorable Mention | 2016 |
| Howard Zeskind | 1966 |
