Football All-Americans
| Name | Organization | Team | Year |
| "A" | |||
| Russell G. Ashbaugh | Walter Camp | Third Team | 1911, 1912 |
| "B" | |||
| Ray Barry | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1960, 1961 |
| Thomas Barry | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1902 |
| Charles E. Blount | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1939 |
| Thomas Budrewicz | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1958 |
| Joseph E. Buonanno | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1932, 1933 |
| Zach Burns | Associated Press | First Team | 1998 |
| Zach Burns | ESPN/USA Today | First Team | 1998 |
| Zach Burns | Football Gazette | First Team | 1998 |
| "C" | |||
| Maury Caito | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1933 |
| Stephen Campbell | Associated Press | Second Team | 1999 |
| Stephen Campbell | Associated Press | First Team | 2000 |
| Stephen Campbell | ESPN/USA Today | First Team | 2000 |
| Stephen Campbell | Football Gazette | Second Team | 1999 |
| Stephen Campbell | Football Gazette | First Team | 2000 |
| Stephen Campbell | The Sports Network | Third Team | 1999 |
| Stephen Campbell | The Sports Network | First Team | 2000 |
| Stephen Campbell | Walter Camp | First Team | 2000 |
| Larry Carbone | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1980 |
| Walt Cataldo | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1986, 1987 |
| Tom Catena | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1985 |
| Robert R. Chase | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1932 |
| Paul Choquette | Football Gazette | First Team | 1996 |
| Paul J. Choquette | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1958, 1959 |
| John Cioci | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1937 |
| J.P.E. "Jack" Cokefair | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1943 |
| Albert C. Cornsweet | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1926, 1928 |
| Donald E. Corzine | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1942 |
| George M. Crowther | Walter Camp | First Team | 1912 |
| John Cuozzo | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1987 |
| Pat Curran | Football Gazette | Third Team | 2005 |
| Steve Curtin | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1980 |
| "D" | |||
| Frank Dennie | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1908 |
| Zak DeOssie | Associated Press | Third Team | 2005 |
| Zak DeOssie | Associated Press | Second Team | 2006 |
| Zak DeOssie | Football Gazette | Third Team | 2004, 2005 |
| Zak DeOssie | Football Gazette | Second Team | 2006 |
| Zak DeOssie | The Sports Network | Second Team | 2006 |
| Harold Detwiler | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1940 |
| Thomas F. Dorsey | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1946 |
| "F" | |||
| Louis Farber | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1926, 1928 |
| Bob Farnham | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1976 |
| Buddy Farnham | The Sports Network | Third Team | 2007 |
| Jay Fidler | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1942 |
| Edward J. Finn | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1946, 1948 |
| Frank H. Finney | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1958 |
| Edward A. Fiorentino | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1943 |
| Albert M. Fletcher | Walter Camp | Third Team | 1905 |
| William "Linc" Fogarty | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1929 |
| Frank B. Folster | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1937 |
| Bob Forster | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1979 |
| David L. Fultz | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1897 |
| "G" | |||
| Jamie Gasparella | Associated Press | Third Team | 2005 |
| Chas Gessner | Associated Press | Second Team | 2001, 2002 |
| Chas Gessner | Football Gazette | First Team | 2001 |
| Chas Gessner | The Sports Network | Second Team | 2001, 2002 |
| Thomas F. Gilbane | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1932 |
| William J. Gilbane | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1932 |
| Jeff Gradinger | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1982 |
| George W. "Woody" Grimshaw | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1946 |
| Mike Gulian | Walter Camp | Third Team | 1922 |
| "H" | |||
| Bob Hall | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1965 |
| Irving "Shine" Hall | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1937, 1938 |
| Nick Hartigan | AFCA | First Team | 2005 |
| Nick Hartigan | Associated Press | First Team | 2005 |
| Nick Hartigan | ESPN/USA Today | First Team | 2005 |
| Nick Hartigan | Football Gazette | Second Team | 2004 |
| Nick Hartigan | Football Gazette | First Team | 2005 |
| Nick Hartigan | The Sports Network | Third Team | 2004 |
| Nick Hartigan | The Sports Network | First Team | 2005 |
| Nick Hartigan | Walter Camp | First Team | 2005 |
| Jack W. Hawley | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1937 |
| Richard T. High | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1941 |
| Milton Hodosh | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1949 |
| Frederick E. Huggins | Walter Camp | Third Team | 1918 |
| "J" | |||
| Steve Jordan | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1980 |
| Harry Josephson | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1954 |
| "K" | |||
| William J. Karaban | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1934 |
| Joe Karcutskie | Football Gazette | Honorable Mention | 1996 |
| Jackson M. Keefer | Walter Camp | Third Team | 1924, 1925 |
| Edwin A. Kevorkian | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1926, 1928 |
| Peter Kohut | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1954 |
| Alex Kos | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1987 |
| Daniel H. Kulp | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1912 |
| Greg Kylish | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1988 |
| "L" | |||
| Richard R. Laine | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1960 |
| James Lalikos | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1945 |
| George Lear | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1932 |
| "M" | |||
| Paul F. Mackesey | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1930, 1931 |
| Steward MacNeil | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1942 |
| Joe Madden | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1988 |
| Spencer Mandrodt | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1937, 1938, 1939 |
| Henry "Rob" Margarita | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1941, 1942 |
| John Marsolini | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1940 |
| John W. Mayhew | Walter Camp | First Team | 1906 |
| John W. Mayhew | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1908 |
| Jon McCabe | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1980 |
| Dan McClutchy | Football Gazette | Honorable Mention | 1997 |
| Jason McCullough | Football Gazette | Honorable Mention | 1996 |
| James McGuinness | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1955 |
| J. Russell McKay | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1910 |
| John J. McLaughry | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1937, 1938, 1939 |
| Frank Meadow | Associated Press | Third Team | 1932 |
| David Mishel | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1926 |
| David Mishel | Grantland Rice | Second Team | 1927 |
| Sean Morey | Associated Press | Second Team | 1997 |
| Sean Morey | ESPN/USA Today | Second Team | 1998 |
| Sean Morey | Football Gazette | First Team | 1997 |
| Irvinwg Morris | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1945 |
| Ted Moskala | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1985 |
| "N" | |||
| Charles Nott | Walter Camp | Third Team | 1895 |
| "O" | |||
| John O'Leary | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1940 |
| "P" | |||
| John Parry | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1963, 1964 |
| Roderic Parson | Football Gazette | First Team | 1997 |
| John "Jay" Pattee | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1942 |
| Bill Perry | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1987 |
| John Pietro | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1951 |
| F.D. "Fritz" Pollard | Walter Camp | First Team | 1916 |
| Jamie Potkul | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1985 |
| John Prodgers | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1937, 1939 |
| Clair J. Purdy | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1916 |
| "R" | |||
| Roy "Red" Randall | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1926 |
| Paul Raymond | The Sports Network | Third Team | 2007 |
| Louis Regine | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1942 |
| Adrian E. Regnier | Walter Camp | First Team | 1909 |
| Bruce Remick | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1942 |
| W.B. Richardson | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1898, 1899 |
| Gilbert Robertshaw | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1956 |
| Edward N. Robinson | Walter Camp | Third Team | 1895 |
| Nelson J. "Jack" Rohrback | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1960 |
| Greg Roth | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1985 |
| "S" | |||
| Daniel "Doc" Savage | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1942, 1943 |
| Ernest T. Savignano | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1940 |
| Joseph Sawyer | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1931 |
| Lou Schepp | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1970 |
| Bertrand L. Shurtleff | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1921 |
| Charles E. Sisson | Walter Camp | Third Team | 1910 |
| Brent G. Smith | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1910 |
| Orland F. Smith | Associated Press | Third Team | 1926 |
| Orland F. Smith | Grantland Rice | First Team | 1926 |
| William E. Sprackling | Walter Camp | Third Team | 1909 |
| William E. Sprackling | Walter Camp | First Team | 1910 |
| William E. Sprackling | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1911 |
| Roy H. Swingler | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1946 |
| "T" | |||
| T.D. Thompson | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1953 |
| "W" | |||
| Gerard E. "Bucky" Walters | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1949 |
| Donald J. Warburton | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1957, 1958 |
| Bob Warden | Associated Press | Third Team | 1994 |
| Joshua H. Weeks | Walter Camp | Second Team | 1918 |
| Tyler Wolfram | Associated Press | Honorable Mention | 1987 |
| John Woodring |
Associated Press | Honorable Mention |
1980 |
