Fencing All-Americans
| Name | Team | Year |
| Mark Dembitz | Second Team | 2002 |
| Paul Friedman | First Team | 2001 |
| Paul Friedman | Third Team | 2002 |
| Sarah Hobstetter | Second Team | 2000 |
| Simon Jones | Honorable Mention | 2015 |
| Simon Jones | Honorable Mention | 2016 |
| Adam Pantel | Honorable Mention | 2009 |
| Ruth Schneider | Second Team | 2003, 2004 |
| Kelly McGuire | Honorable Mention | 2013 |
