All Time Academic All-Ivy
| Name | Sport | Year(s) - Listed year is academic season in which the athlete was awarded |
| Rene Abdalah | Football | 1992, 1993, 1994 |
| Gerrit Adams | Water Polo | 2006 |
| Jeremy Adler | Fencing | 2006 |
| Vik Agrawal | Tennis | 1993 |
| Uwa Airhiavbere | Football | 2001 |
| Jordin Alexander | Basketball | 2016 |
| Julie Amato | Basketball | 1999 |
| Mike Amato | Golf | 2011 |
| Rachel Anderson | Crew | 2000 |
| Erin Andrews | Squash | 2007 |
| Mark Arrigan | Baseball | 1994 |
| Alessandra Assante | Fencing | 2004 |
| Sarah Atkinson | Outdoor Track | 1994 |
| Sarah Atkinson | Cross Country | 1993, 1994 |
| Kendrick Au | Tennis | 2011 |
| Catherine Auriemma | Field Hockey | 2007 |
| Jennifer Bachus | Crew | 1997 |
| Taylor Bantle | Volleyball | 2014 |
| Tori Barbata | Water Polo | 2003 |
| David Bailey | Squash | 2005, 2006 |
| Elizabeth Balassone | Water Polo | 2005, 2007 |
| Bridget Ballard | Soccer | 2008, 2009 |
| Joel Barone | Football | 2002 |
| MC Barrett | Soccer | 2013 |
| Amy Baxter | Softball | 2008 |
| Charlotte Beach | Soccer | 2015 |
| Quincy Beck | Squash | 2017, 2018 |
| Marcus Becker | Basketball | 2006 |
| Arden Beddoes | Crew | 2005 |
| Anna Bengtson | Skiing | 2009 |
| Holleigh Bergstrom | Outdoor Track | 2014 |
| Morgan Bernius | Soccer | 1994, 1995 |
| Ophir Bernstein | Wrestling | 2014 |
| Rachel Biblo | Outdoor Track | 2011 |
| Rufus Biggs | Crew | 2019 |
| Sophie Bikofsky | Basketball | 2015 |
| Chelsey Binkley | Gymnastics | 2010, 2011 |
| Jack Blasberg | Squash | 2016 |
| Alexis Blaxberg | Water Polo | 2008 |
| Thomas Blecher | Squash | 2018 |
| Amber Bledsoe | Soccer | 2012 |
| Eric Block | Soccer | 1995, 1996 |
| Ray Bobrownicki | Indoor Track | 2005 |
| Igor Boraska | Crew | 1994 |
| Anthony Borelli | Ice Hockey | 2013 |
| Briana Borgolini | Swimming | 2014 |
| Andrea Boudreau | Ice Hockey | 1994, 1995 |
| Travis Bouscaren | Water Polo | 2018 |
| Brad Bowery | Indoor Track | 2003 |
| Ben Brackett | Soccer | 2006 |
| Cindy Bradeen | Squash | 1995, 1996 |
| Diana Brainard | Squash | 1992 |
| Louise Breen | Crew | 2014 |
| Emily Brennan | Field Hockey | 1998 |
| Ali Brewer | Ice Hockey | 1998, 1999, 2000 |
| Matt Britner | Soccer | 2007 |
| Chad Broome-Webster | Football | 2020 |
| Ajani Brown | Outdoor Track | 2014 |
| Brett Brown | Football | 1992 |
| Cameron Brown | Soccer | 2020 |
| Parker Brown | Lacrosse | 2012 |
| Adam Buchanan | Soccer | 2001 |
| Jessica Buck | Gymnastics | 2001 |
| Charlie Buckley | Football | 1993 |
| Mark Buda | Outdoor Track | 2017 |
| Chris Burke | Cross Country | 2005 |
| Gerry Burke | Ice Hockey | 2005 |
| Jordan Burke | Lacrosse | 2008, 2009 |
| Rico Burke | Water Polo | 2017 |
| Nicole Burns | Indoor Track | 2008 |
| Nate Burroughs | Wrestling | 1999 |
| Hannah Butler | Cross Country | 2019 |
| Ian Butterbrodt | Wrestling | 2019 |
| Lizzie Buza | Field Hockey | 2001, 2002, 2003 |
| Niki Caggiano | Lacrosse | 2001, 2002 |
| Maura Cahill | Gymnastics | 1998 |
| Melissa Cairo | Volleyball | 2017 |
| Sue Calder | Softball | 1992, 1993 |
| Alexa Caldwell | Lacrosse | 2011 |
| Heidi Caldwell | Cross Country | 2012, 2013 |
| Cristina Caligiuri | Crew | 2009 |
| Mark Callahan | Football | 2009 |
| Hannah Camhi | Tennis | 2015, 2016 |
| Stephen Campbell | Football | 1999 |
| Abby Carchio | Soccer | 2018 |
| Marjorie Carges | Swimming | 1994 |
| Dan Carr | Golf | 1995 |
| Edward Cerullo | Squash | 2008 |
| Sienna Chapman | Golf | 2017 |
| Phil Charm | Tennis | 2006 |
| Gordon Chen | Football | 2000 |
| Kristie Chin | Softball | 2010 |
| Albert Cho | Squash | 1994 |
| Tamenang Choh | Basketball | 2021 |
| Nick Ciarcia | Wrestling | 2002, 2003, 2004 |
| Robbie Clark | Indoor Track | 1995 |
| Lauren Clarke | Basketball | 2013, 2014 |
| Beth Clifton | Rugby | 2016 |
| Colin Cloherty | Football | 2008 |
| Evan Coleman | Soccer | 2010 |
| Tricia Colligan | Field Hockey | 1994 |
| Margaret Connelly | Cross Country | 2012 |
| Kathryn Conner | Volleyball | 2013, 2014 |
| Patrick Conroy | Football | 2010 |
| Krista Consiglio | Skiing | 2010, 2011 |
| Chris Contrino | Baseball | 2005 |
| Tori Cook | Soccer | 1991 |
| Jessie Cooper | Volleyball | 2000, 2001, 2002 |
| Michael Coppolino | Indoor Track | 2020 |
| David Coughlin | Crew | 2006, 2007 |
| Allison Courtin | Crew | 2012 |
| Katie Cowan | Swimming | 1999, 2000 |
| Tom Crain | Baseball | 1992, 1993 |
| Adom Crew | Soccer | 2002, 2003 |
| Meredith Crocker | Cross Country | 2003 |
| Tyler Crone | Crew | 1996 |
| Sarah Cronin | Swimming | 2017 |
| Sarah Crosky | Squash | 2012 |
| Christian Crynes | Crew | 2009 |
| Gavin Crynes | Crew | 2010 |
| Sydney Cummings | Soccer | 2019 |
| Lindsay Cunningham | Soccer | 2007, 2008 |
| Russell Curley | Indoor Track | 1993, 1994 |
| Russell Curley | Outdoor Track | 1994 |
| Russell Curley | Cross Country | 1993 |
| Kate Cushing | Outdoor Track | 2003 |
| Marisol Dakan | Water Polo | 2018 |
| McKenna Dale | Basketball | 2021 |
| Mia Dammen | Soccer | 1993, 1994 |
| Andrew Daniels | Soccer | 2006 |
| Steve Daniels | Baseball | 2009 |
| Yann Danis | Ice Hockey | 2002 |
| Anya Davidson | Cross Country | 2005 |
| Hunter Davis | Ice Hockey | 2015 |
| Neville Davy | Indoor Track | 1998 |
| Sara Dawes | Soccer | 1996, 1997 |
| Steve DeBrun | Squash | 1992 |
| Bobby Deeb | Baseball | 2003 |
| Chris Deegan | Wrestling | 1997 |
| Armen Deirmenjian | Water Polo | 2019 |
| Shanelle DeJournett | Outdoor Track | 2017 |
| Dillon Delaney | Swimming | 2008 |
| Matt DelMastro | Swimming | 2005 |
| Clay Del Prince | Lacrosse | 2013 |
| Mark Dembitz | Fencing | 2002 |
| Constantine Demetracopoulos | Crew | 2002 |
| Pascal Denis | Ice Hockey | 2003 |
| Cynthia DeRosa | Field Hockey | 1991 |
| Sean Dersch | Ice Hockey | 2007 |
| Sloan DeRoss | Crew | 1999 |
| Mimi DeTolla | Lacrosse | 2007 |
| Peter DeYoung | Baseball | 1997, 1998, 1999 |
| Mike DiBiase | Baseball | 2011 |
| Alyssa DiBona | Lacrosse | 2015 |
| Doria DiBona | Skiing | 2002, 2003 |
| Elizabeth DiBona | Skiing | 2001 |
| Annalisa DiChiara | Soccer | 1991 |
| Strider Dickson | Lacrosse | 1998, 1999 |
| Joe DiGiacomo | Football | 2006 |
| Daveed Diggs | Outdoor Track | 2004 |
| Andy Dixon | Soccer | 1998 |
| Sam Donovan | Hockey | 2018 |
| Michael Dougherty | Football | 2008 |
| Chris Drake | Tennis | 2001, 2003 |
| Emily Dreblow | Soccer | 1998 |
| Deborah Dryer | Crew | 2005, 2006 |
| Olivia Duba | Rugby | 2019 |
| Angela Dunn | Volleyball | 2001 |
| Darren Eales | Soccer | 1993, 1994 |
| Sara Eaton | Field Hockey | 2008 |
| Brian Ellixson | Football | 2010 |
| Zack Emrich | Indoor Track | 2017 |
| David Enemark | Crew | 2003 |
| Amanda Engelhardt | Skiing | 2014, 2015 |
| Leigh Ernst | Lacrosse | 1993 |
| Christine Etzel | Soccer | 2018 |
| Peter Fallon | Lacrosse | 2011 |
| Jay Fantone | Water Polo | 2004 |
| Amy Farley | Volleyball | 1995, 1996 |
| Bobby Farnham | Ice Hockey | 2012 |
| Jeff Feingold | Soccer | 1991 |
| Todd Feltus | Cross Country | 1994 |
| Anea Ferrario | Hockey | 2021 |
| Paul Fichiera | Football | 1995 |
| Dave Filippone | Crew | 1995 |
| Geoff Finch | Ice Hockey | 1993, 1994 |
| Corey Finnerty-Ludwig | Crew | 2008 |
| Jayne Finst | Gymnastics | 2002, 2003, 2004 |
| Joe Fiqua | Crew | 2000 |
| Tara Fiscella | Golf | 2001, 2002, 2003 |
| Elise Fishelson | Equestrian | 2011 |
| Alex Fleming | Crew | 2012 |
| Craig Foisie | Water Polo | 1997 |
| Amanda Forte | Equestrian | 2000, 2002 |
| Chris Fox | Soccer | 1994, 1995 |
| Henry Fox | Water Polo | 2014 |
| Dave Foxen | Wrestling | 2012 |
| Sarah Fraidin | Squash | 1993 |
| Spencer Freedman | Tennis | 1992 |
| Anne Friedland | Soccer | 2007 |
| Paul Friedman | Fencing | 2000 |
| Krista Fulton | Soccer | 1995 |
| Steven Galiardo | Wrestling | 2016, 2017 |
| David Galluzzi | Swimming | 1995 |
| Susana Garcia | Field Hockey | 1999, 2000 |
| Margaret Gardel | Crew | 1998 |
| Cara Gardner | Ice Hockey | 2001 |
| Mike Gartner | Water Polo | 2007, 2008 |
| Jeff Gaudette | Outdoor Track | 2003 |
| Jeff Gaudette | Cross Country | 2003 |
| Justine Gaziano | Basketball | 2020 |
| Samantha Gehring | Lacrosse | 1994 |
| Morgan Gerlak | Crew | 2013, 2014 |
| Cory Gibbs | Soccer | 2000 |
| Lauren Gibbs | Volleyball | 2005 |
| Anastasia Gillen | Soccer | 2014 |
| Zach Giuttari | Hockey | 2019 |
| Tommy Glenn | Swimming | 2014 |
| Tessa Gobbo | Crew | 2013 |
| Katie Goddard | Gymnastics | 2012 |
| Nick Goldberg | Tennis | 2004, 2005 |
| Jake Golenor | Indoor Track | 2006 |
| Jake Golenor | Outdoor Track | 2005 |
| Jack Gorab | Soccer | 2014, 2015 |
| Geoff Gotlieb | Swimming | 1998 |
| Rachel Gottlieb | Crew | 2014, 2015 |
| Carly Gould | Soccer | 2015, 2016 |
| Ryan Graddy | Outdoor Track | 2008 |
| Paul Grandstrand | Soccer | 2009 |
| Lucy Green | Field Hockey | 2016 |
| Peter Greskoff | Baseball | 2010 |
| Sam Grigo | Baseball | 2017 |
| Caroline Grogan | Crew | 1999 |
| Emily Grossman | Cross Country | 1997 |
| Eliza Grover | Volleyball | 2019 |
| Brittnay Grovey | Indoor Track | 2005, 2006 |
| Danielle Grunloh | Indoor Track | 2009, 2010 |
| Ali Gunesch | Skiing | 2016, 2017 |
| Smita Gupta | Cross Country | 2006, 2007 |
| Dave Gustovich | Wrestling | 1994 |
| Larry Haertel | Golf | 2007 |
| Holly Hagens | Soccer | 1992 |
| Daphne Halaris | Lacrosse | 1992, 1993 |
| Dan Hanegby | Tennis | 2007 |
| Kathy Hannon | Volleyball | 1992 |
| Kathy Hannon | Crew | 1993, 1994 |
| Derrick Hansen | Swimming | 1992 |
| Emma Hansen | Gymnastics | 2020 |
| Ben Hardt | Fencing | 1999 |
| Duriel Hardy | Cross Country | 2008 |
| Duriel Hardy | Indoor Track | 2009, 2010 |
| Duriel Hardy | Outdoor Track | 2009, 2010 |
| Nelson Hargrove | Golf | 2013, 2014 |
| Tara Harrington | Field Hockey | 1992, 1993 |
| Livingstone Harriott | Football | 2019 |
| Kelley Harrison | Field Hockey | 2012 |
| Nick Hartigan | Football | 2003, 2004, 2005 |
| Jennifer Hausmann | Fencing | 2007 |
| Katherine Hawrot | Fencing | 2013, 2014 |
| Sarah Hayes | Basketball | 2005, 2006 |
| Grace Healy | Lacrosse | 2014 |
| Sarah Hebert-Seropian | Soccer | 2011 |
| Gabrielle Hechtman | Gymnastics | 2019 |
| Ellie Heckscher | Fencing | 1996 |
| Keira Heggie | Water Polo | 2004 |
| Doran Heist | Wrestling | 2005 |
| Julie Herrold | Soccer | 2003 |
| Cassandra Herzberg | Tennis | 2011 |
| Kelsey Hiatt | Swimming | 2002 |
| Kim Highlund | Volleyball | 2003 |
| Brent Hoiness | Ice Hockey | 1998 |
| Graham Holland | Squash | 1995, 1996 |
| Kent Holland | Water Polo | 2009 |
| Jason Holowaty | Baseball | 1995 |
| Mike Hsu | Water Polo | 1996 |
| Charlie Humber | Ice Hockey | 1995, 1996 |
| Scott Humber | Ice Hockey | 1996 |
| Doug Humphrey | Indoor Track | 1999, 2000 |
| Zach Hunsaker | Basketball | 2020 |
| Sam Hurster | Lacrosse | 2014 |
| Katie Hyland | Field Hockey | 2009, 2010 |
| Venkatesh Iyer | Tennis | 1998 |
| Devon Jack | Tennis | 2020 |
| Kristin Jackson | Swimming | 2013 |
| Richard "Dewey" Jarvis | Football | 2016, 2017 |
| Carleen Jeffers | Cross Country | 2018 |
| Sean Jensen | Football | 2001 |
| Martina Jerant | Basketball | 1993 |
| Stacey Johansen | Softball | 1994 |
| Christina Johnson | Basketball | 2010 |
| Courtney Johnson | Ice Hockey | 2002, 2003 |
| Enda Johnson | Cross Country | 1999, 2000, 2001 |
| Enda Johnson | Indoor Track | 2001 |
| Portia Johnson | Crew | 2001 |
| Scott Johnston | Water Polo | 1995 |
| Simon Jones | Fencing | 2016 |
| Tanya Jones | Indoor Track | 1994 |
| Julian Jordan | Soccer | 2002 |
| Allison Kagawa | Soccer | 2010, 2011 |
| Anna Kaneb | Field Hockey | 2020 |
| Dan Kantrovitz | Baseball | 1999, 2001 |
| Jason Katz | Indoor Track | 2019 |
| Whitney Keefe | Equestrian | 2007, 2008 |
| Julia Kelderman | Field Hockey | 2004 |
| Becky Kellar | Softball | 1995, 1996, 1997 |
| Becky Kellar | Ice Hockey | 1997 |
| Julia Keller | Lacrosse | 2012 |
| Brian Kelly | Swimming | 2008 |
| Jack Kelly | Lacrosse | 2015 |
| Casey Kelsey | Crew | 2011 |
| Larken Kemp | Lacrosse | 2016 |
| Nancy Kendall | Lacrosse | 1994, 1995 |
| Devon Kennedy | Squash | 1999 |
| Sam Kernan-Schloss | Soccer | 2011, 2012 |
| Doug Kezirian | Water Polo | 1999, 2000 |
| Erin Khniholm | Crew | 1995 |
| Ryan Kikuchi | Swimming | 2011 |
| Christine Kim | Golf | 2016 |
| Melissa Kim | Soccer | 2009 |
| Craig Kinsley | Outdoor Track | 2010, 2011 |
| Tyler Kirchberg | Water Polo | 2017 |
| Shawn Kitchner | Wrestling | 2006, 2007 |
| Kari Klassen | Swimming | 1998 |
| Kevin Klein | Wrestling | 1996 |
| William Klein | Water Polo | 2015 |
| Phoebe Koch | Lacrosse | 1997, 1998 |
| Samuel Koch | Fencing | 2018 |
| Sharod Kohli | Tennis | 1999 |
| Marisa Kolokotronis | Water Polo | 2017 |
| Julia Komosinski | Cross Country | 2004 |
| Terence Kooyker | Crew | 2004 |
| Ryan Kopec | Football | 2018 |
| Noah Korotzer | Outdoor Track | 2020 |
| Margaret Kosmala | Fencing | 1999, 2000 |
| Paul Krasinski | Basketball | 1998 |
| Misia Krasowski | Tennis | 2012, 2013 |
| Cedric Kuakumensah | Basketball | 2016 |
| Elvina Kung | Volleyball | 2004 |
| John Kunschner | Golf | 1996 |
| Matt Kutler | Baseball | 2002 |
| Steve Lacy | Soccer | 1991 |
| Sam Lafferty | Hockey | 2017, 2018 |
| Cynthia Lake | Lacrosse | 1996 |
| Jessica Lanning | Crew | 2002 |
| Rachel Lanouette | Field Hockey | 2017, 2018 |
| Page Lansing | Water Polo | 2006 |
| Kim Lanzire | Soccer | 2000, 2001 |
| Katie Lapinski | Volleyball | 2006 |
| Jessica Larson | Swimming | 2005, 2006 |
| Amy Latinen | Swimming | 2007 |
| Kim LaVere | Soccer | 2005 |
| Jeff Lawler | Baseball | 2000 |
| Adrian Leanza | Squash | 2011 |
| Jenn Lears | Swimming | 2001 |
| Emma LeBlanc | Skiing | 2013 |
| Hannah Leckey | Field Hockey | 2019 |
| Chris Lee | Tennis | 2008, 2009 |
| Jarrett Leech | Soccer | 2008 |
| Garrett Leffelman | Basketball | 2010 |
| Maclaine Lehan | Soccer | 2017 |
| Louise Leitao | Rugby | 2018 |
| Ellen Lenihan | Basketball | 1994 |
| Mike Levin | Lacrosse | 2004 |
| Jake Levine | Baseball | 2015, 2016 |
| Zion Lewis | Outdoor Track | 2019 |
| Zion Lewis | Indoor Track | 2020 |
| Kevin Li | Golf | 2016, 2018 |
| Miles Libbey | Swimming | 1993 |
| Lauren Libfraind | Crew | 2010 |
| Lauren Linder | Outdoor Track | 2004 |
| Bronson Lingamfelter | Wrestling | 2001 |
| Christine Livoti | Fencing | 2008 |
| Rick Lloyd | Basketball | 1992 |
| Samantha Lloyd | Field Hockey | 2005, 2006 |
| Sasha Lobel | Golf | 2018 |
| John Loeser | Cross Country | 2009 |
| Emerson Logie | Football | 2019 |
| Joe Lomuscio | Baseball | 2020 |
| Matt Lorito | Ice Hockey | 2015 |
| Nathan Lovett | Football | 2011 |
| Dan Lowry | Cross Country | 2011 |
| Dan Lowry | Outdoor Track | 2012 |
| Catherine Luke | Volleyball | 1993, 1994 |
| Libby Lyons | Soccer | 1997 |
| Rachael MacDonald | Basketball | 2000 |
| Jack Maclellan | Ice Hockey | 2011, 2012 |
| Brian Madden | Crew | 1993 |
| Dan Mahoney | Fencing | 2007 |
| Matt Mahoney | Cross Country | 2016 |
| Rafael Maia | Basketball | 2015 |
| Nick Malone | Tennis | 2001, 2002 |
| Natascha Mangan | Swimming | 2011 |
| Mira Manickam | Outdoor Track | 1999 |
| Jordan Mann | Cross Country | 2014 |
| Sara Mansur | Tennis | 2009 |
| Alex Markes | Soccer | 2014 |
| Eliza Marshall | Soccer | 2011 |
| Oliver Marti | Lacrosse | 1992, 1993 |
| Martin Martinez | Cross Country | 2017 |
| Mark McAndrew | Basketball | 2007, 2008 |
| Luke McCaleb | Lacrosse | 2019, 2020 |
| Rob McCann | Swimming | 1992 |
| Emily McCoy | Swimming | 2003, 2004 |
| Keely McDonald | Lacrosse | 2000 |
| Maigrie McDougal | Water Polo | 2019 |
| Ryan McDuff | Soccer | 2012 |
| Luke McGee | Crew | 2000, 2001 |
| Will McGettigan | Lacrosse | 2006 |
| Sean McGonagill | Basketball | 2014 |
| Annie McGregor | Softball | 2017 |
| Kelly McGuire | Fencing | 2013 |
| Mary McMains | Volleyball | 1997 |
| Bridget McNamara | Field Hockey | 2011 |
| James McNamara | Water Polo | 2013 |
| Shannon McSweeney | Field Hockey | 2013, 2014 |
| Rob Medairos | Soccer | 2011 |
| Finn Meeks | Crew | 2017 |
| Shayna Mehta | Basketball | 2018, 2019 |
| Darby Melia | Hockey | 2021 |
| Erin Meschter | Outdoor Track | 2005 |
| Josh Meyer | Basketball | 2002 |
| Natalie Meyers | Volleyball | 2007, 2008 |
| Olivia Mickle | Outdoor Track | 2012 |
| Jeff Miksis | Swimming | 2001 |
| Walker Mills | Crew | 2015 |
| Lindsay Minges | Lacrosse | 2013 |
| Jorden Mitchell | Gymnastics | 2016 |
| Nyema Mitchell | Basketball | 2004 |
| Levon Mock | Wrestling | 2008 |
| Jeremy Modell | Golf | 1994 |
| Dylan Molloy | Lacrosse | 2017 |
| Ruby Moore-Bloom | Crew | 2017 |
| Jefferson Moors | Swimming | 2002, 2003, 2004 |
| Kathryn Moos | Soccer | 2006 |
| Caroline Morant | Gymnastics | 2017 |
| Jimmy Mormile | Lacrosse | 2002 |
| Michele Mortensen | Ice Hockey | 1996 |
| Kia Mosenthal | Skiing | 2012 |
| Risa Mosenthal | Lacrosse | 2020 |
| Michelle Moses | Softball | 2009 |
| Maximo Moyer | Squash | 2020 |
| Amy Mulligan | Field Hockey | 1991, 1992 |
| Alison Mullin | Soccer | 2012, 2013 |
| Matt Mullery | Basketball | 2009 |
| Lucia Murphy | Ice Hockey | 1992 |
| James Myall | Soccer | 2016, 2017 |
| Mark Naclerio | Ice Hockey | 2016 |
| Tomo Nakanishi | Volleyball | 1999 |
| Laurel Naverson | Swimming | 1996 |
| Jade Newburn | Basketball | 1997 |
| Jackson Newsome | Lacrosse | 2018 |
| Jaqueline Nicewarmer | Field Hockey | 1993 |
| John Nicholson | Tennis | 1996 |
| Gavin Nieto | Hockey | 2020 |
| Mike Nobel | Ice hockey | 1997 |
| Jeff Nord | Indoor Track | 1999 |
| Alexander Norocea | Football | 2013 |
| Santiago Nunez | Water Polo | 2018 |
| Meghan O'Donnell | Field Hockey | 2014 |
| Kelly O'Hear | Skiing | 2006, 2007 |
| Brendan O'Keefe | Indoor Track | 2004 |
| Kevin O'Sullivan | Water Polo | 1998 |
| Anna Odell | Crew | 2019, 2020 |
| Obi Okolie | Basketball | 2019 |
| Uzoamaka Okoro | Rugby | 2015 |
| Rick Olczyk | Ice Hockey | 1992 |
| Rylee Olewinski | Ice Hockey | 2007 |
| Uchenna Omokaro | Softball | 2004 |
| Annie Owens | Field Hockey | 2000 |
| Adewole Oyalowo | Football | 2013 |
| Tosin Oyewole | Indoor Track | 2018 |
| Noel Pacarro | Water Polo | 2001, 2002 |
| Carolyn Paletta | Lacrosse | 2018 |
| Melissa Panchuck | Softball | 1998 |
| Adam Pantel | Fencing | 2009, 2010 |
| Hannah Passafuime | Basketball | 2011, 2012 |
| Trishna Patel | Tennis | 1997 |
| Carly Paul | Indoor Track | 2017, 2018 |
| Carly Paul | Outdoor Track | 2018 |
| Kimani Paul-Emile | Indoor Track | 1992, 1993 |
| Kimani Paul-Emile | Outdoor Track | 1992, 1993 |
| Michelle Pautler | Tennis | 2007 |
| Steve Peck | Water Polo | 1994 |
| Jamie Peddy | Equestrian | 2006 |
| AJ Pedro | Wrestling | 2021 |
| Jim Pedro | Wrestling | 1993 |
| Cory Pelletier | Field Hockey | 2002 |
| Jayson Pereira | Cross Country | 1995, 1996 |
| Christopher Perkins | Football | 2009 |
| James Perry | Football | 1997 |
| Scott Perry | Football | 1991 |
| Riley Pestorius | Swimming | 2021 |
| Tom Peters | Lacrosse | 1992 |
| Thomas Phelps | Crew | 2020 |
| Laurel Pierpont | Lacrosse | 2004 |
| JD Pinto | Swimming | 2010 |
| Lauren Pischel | Cross Country | 2010 |
| Andrea Posa | Field Hockey | 2006 |
| Laura Powers | Swimming | 1992 |
| Patrick Powers | Basketball | 2003, 2004 |
| Scott Powers | Soccer | 1999, 2000 |
| Karen Prazar | Crew | 2003, 2004 |
| Lauren Presant | Water Polo | 2009, 2010 |
| Brendan Prindiville | Cross Country | 1998 |
| Laura Pyne | Squash | 2010 |
| Will Quigley | Football | 2015 |
| Bob Quinnell | Ice Hockey | 1998 |
| Adrian Rapp | Soccer | 2001 |
| Megan Ratcliffe | Cross Country | 2017 |
| Paul Raymond | Indoor Track | 2007 |
| Paul Raymond | Football | 2007 |
| Conor Reardon | Baseball | 2008 |
| Kevin Reed | Swimming | 1994 |
| Dylan Remick | Soccer | 2012 |
| Peter Rhodes | Indoor Track | 2014, 2015 |
| Kathryn Rice | Volleyball | 1998 |
| Daniel Ricketts | Swimming | 2009 |
| David Robertson | Ice Hockey | 2008 |
| Dennis Robertson | Ice Hockey | 2013, 2014 |
| Brent Robinson | Ice Hockey | 2004 |
| Kelly Robinson | Lacrosse | 2009 |
| Bretram Rogers | Indoor Track | 2021 |
| Elizabeth Rogers | Lacrosse | 1999 |
| Hannah Rogers | Field Hockey | 2015 |
| Marcos Rollan | Tennis | 1997 |
| Marcos Romaneiro | Soccer | 2003, 2004 |
| Charlotte Rose | Fencing | 2009 |
| Nick Rosenberg | Squash | 1997 |
| Dave Rosenstein | Soccer | 1992 |
| Lillian Rosenthal | Squash | 2003, 2005 |
| Paul Rosiak | Outdoor Track | 2007 |
| Bekah Rottenberg | Lacrosse | 2003 |
| Rupert Roxburgh | Crew | 1997 |
| Katie Rowinski | Indoor Track | 2004 |
| Elise Roy | Soccer | 1999 |
| Greg Rozycki | Lacrosse | 1995 |
| Virginia Rushing | Soccer | 1996 |
| Owen Russell | Outdoor Track | 2019 |
| Sheryl Ryu | Tennis | 1992 |
| Ian Sady | Golf | 2000 |
| Meredith Saillant | Cross Country | 1991, 1992 |
| Maddie Salesky | Swimming | 2018 |
| Luke Samson | Water Polo | 2006 |
| Saranga Sangakkara | Tennis | 1998, 1999 |
| Olivia Santiago | Water Polo | 2015 |
| Jeanette Saraidaridis | Crew | 2007 |
| Michael Satin | Lacrosse | 1997, 1998 |
| Kate Saul | Crew | 1999, 2000 |
| Susan Scavone | Indoor Track | 2012 |
| David Scherrer | Cross Country | 2020 |
| Allison Schettini | Lacrosse | 1997, 1998 |
| Daniel Schiller | Soccer | 2018, 2019 |
| Jonathon Schlafer | Swimming | 2017 |
| Katy Schmidt | Soccer | 2017 |
| Renee Schnieder | Squash | 1992 |
| Ruth Schnieder | Fencing | 2006 |
| Meghan Schreck | Soccer | 2004 |
| Natalie Schudrowitz | Cross Country | 2015 |
| Corey Schwartz | Water Polo | 2010 |
| Taylor Seaman | Swimming | 2020, 2021 |
| Mary Seid | Softball | 2006 |
| Cat Seitz | Softball | 2019 |
| Reade Seligmann | Lacrosse | 2010 |
| Anna Seto | Equestrian | 2018 |
| Michaela Sewall | Soccer | 2002, 2003 |
| Raj Shah | Crew | 1996 |
| Mina Shakarshy | Squash | 2015 |
| Shane Shapiro | Baseball | 1996 |
| Dylan Sheehan | Soccer | 2007 |
| Erin Sheehy | Lacrosse | 1992 |
| Will Sheeran | Cross Country | 2015 |
| Michelle Shnayder | Gymnastics | 2013, 2014 |
| Betsy Siberry | Soccer | 1998 |
| Greg Silverberg | Crew | 2012 |
| Matt Simmons | Football | 1996, 1997 |
| Jed Simon | Water Polo | 1992 |
| Cody Slaughter | Baseball | 2013 |
| Mark Sluys | Baseball | 2019 |
| Azibo Smith | Football | 1998 |
| Brynn Smith | Indoor Track | 2011 |
| Brynn Smith | Outdoor Track | 2010 |
| Kelly Smith | Soccer | 2001 |
| Peyton Smith | Volleyball | 2016 |
| Ryan Smith | Soccer | 1997 |
| Zack Smith | Indoor Track | 1996 |
| Laura Sobik | Cross Country | 1998, 1999 |
| Jennifer Sobuta | Gymnastics | 2008 |
| Muriel Solberg | Crew | 2016 |
| Sharon Sonenblum | Fencing | 2001, 2002 |
| Paula Spaeth | Indoor Track | 2000 |
| Steven Spieth | Basketball | 2017 |
| Marc Sredojevic | Baseball | 2017 |
| Kate Staley | Lacrosse | 2005, 2006 |
| Jay Stalfort | Lacrosse | 1994 |
| Alex Stanton | Outdoor Track | 2015 |
| Justin Staudenmayer | Wrestling | 2018 |
| Charlotte Steel | Squash | 2009 |
| Svetozar Stefanovic | Water Polo | 2011, 2012 |
| Lisa Stern | Gymnastics | 1993, 1994, 1995 |
| May Stern | Indoor Track | 2019 |
| Benson Stevens | Crew | 2018 |
| Scott Stirling | Ice Hockey | 1999, 2000 |
| Nicole Stock | Ice Hockey | 2008, 2009 |
| Brian Strachan | Football | 2014 |
| Paul Strombom | Crew | 2008 |
| Yamini Subramanian | Field Hockey | 1995, 1996 |
| Chris Sullivan | Lacrosse | 2000, 2001 |
| Coley Sullivan | Swimming | 2019, 2020 |
| Katie Sullivan | Field Hockey | 1997 |
| Matthew Sullivan | Basketball | 2012, 2013 |
| Peter Sullivan | Basketball | 2011 |
| Anna Susini | Fencing | 2021 |
| Hillary Swaffield | Skiing | 2005 |
| Patrick Tarpy | Cross Country | 2002, 2003 |
| Peter Tarwid | Tennis | 2016, 2018 |
| Lindsay Taylor | Outdoor Track | 2000 |
| Nate Taylor | Squash | 1993 |
| Brock Tessman | Outdoor Track | 1998 |
| Bryan Tews | Baseball | 2006 |
| Debbie Thomas | Tennis | 1995 |
| Devin Thomas | Baseball | 2007 |
| Elanor Thomas | Golf | 2005 |
| Brad Thompson | Squash | 2012 |
| Jon Thompson | Lacrosse | 2003 |
| Kenneth Thompson | Outdoor Track | 2013 |
| Stephanie Thompson | Softball | 2012, 2013 |
| James Thygesen | Water Polo | 2019 |
| Sara Tindall | Cross Country | 1999, 2000 |
| Sean Tiner | Water Polo | 2004 |
| Justin To | Tennis | 2015 |
| Vanessa Toney | Indoor Track | 1995 |
| Vanessa Toney | Outdoor Track | 1996 |
| Rodd Torbert | Football | 1991 |
| Lauren Toy | Lacrosse | 2016 |
| Henry Tufnell | Outdoor Track | 2014, 2015 |
| Megan Tuohy | Golf | 2011 |
| David Turner | Football | 2005 |
| Liz Turner | Basketball | 1997, 1998 |
| William Twyman | Football | 2016 |
| Graham Tyler | Baseball | 2012 |
| Ijeoma Uche | Outdoor Track | 2020 |
| Star Urmston | Swimming | 1993 |
| Samantha Valentine | Cross Country | 2020 |
| Erin Vali | Cross Country | 1991, 1992 |
| Erin Vali | Outdoor Track | 1992, 1993 |
| Zoe Verni | Lacrosse | 2019 |
| Caroline Vexler | Swimming | 2016 |
| Kristen Vincent | Field Hockey | 2004, 2005 |
| Lauren Vitkus | Lacrosse | 2008 |
| Matt Vokes | Ice Hockey | 2009 |
| Aaron Volpatti | Ice Hockey | 2010 |
| Kyle Wailes | Lacrosse | 2005 |
| Derek Waleffe | Soccer | 2020 |
| Geoff Walker | Soccer | 1999 |
| Gina Walker | Soccer | 2010 |
| Jacob Walker | Tennis | 2019, 2020 |
| David Walls | Soccer | 2010 |
| Kent Walls | Outdoor Track | 2006 |
| Diana Walters | Gymnastics | 2015 |
| Katrina Walters | Swimming | 1995, 1997 |
| Chris Walther | Football | 2002 |
| Christian Warrington | Ice Hockey | 2001 |
| Owen Washburn | Cross Country | 2005 |
| Paris Waterman | Lacrosse | 2010 |
| Emily Waters | Softball | 2020 |
| William Watterson | Wrestling | 2013, 2015 |
| Ed Watts | Outdoor Track | 1995, 1996, 1997 |
| Ed Watts | Indoor Track | 1997 |
| Simon Weaver | Wrestling | 1995 |
| Josh Weiner | Soccer | 2013 |
| Luke Weiser | Water Polo | 2016 |
| Barrett Weiss | Fencing | 2015 |
| Sarah Welch | Swimming | 2019 |
| Gabe Welp | Soccer | 2018 |
| Duncan Welstead | Swimming | 2000 |
| Dan Wendt | Water Polo | 1993 |
| Ephraim Wernick | Football | 1998 |
| Tim Whalen | Soccer | 2015 |
| Gracie Whelan | Indoor Track | 2020, 2021 |
| Kerri Whitaker | Lacrosse | 1996 |
| Andy Wiener | Water Polo | 2004, 2005 |
| Bobby Wiginton | Baseball | 2004 |
| Kristin Williams | Outdoor Track | 1995 |
| Kristin Williams | Cross Country | 1995, 1996 |
| Kristin Williams | Indoor Track | 1996, 1997 |
| O'Sha Williams | Indoor Track | 2016 |
| O'Sha Williams | Outdoor Track | 2016 |
| Brianna Williamson | Volleyball | 2009, 2010 |
| Ned Willig | Outdoor Track | 2016 |
| Meghan Wimmer | Softball | 2018 |
| Rachel Winer | Skiing | 1997, 1998 |
| Hans Wittusen | Soccer | 1996, 1997 |
| Kaitlyn Wong | Volleyball | 2020 |
| Jesse Wood | Basketball | 2000, 2001 |
| Rosie Woodford | Cross Country | 2002 |
| Kate Woods | Water Polo | 2013, 2014 |
| Taylor Worthy | Cross Country | 2016 |
| Ariel Wright | Cross Country | 2008, 2009 |
| Ed Yoon | Golf | 2002 |
| Heather Young | Tennis | 2001 |
| Isabel Young | Squash | 2019 |
| Michael Yules | Football | 2012, 2013 |
| Ari Zamir | Cross Country | 2007 |
| Harry Zolnierczyk | Ice Hockey | 2011 |
