.png&width=60&height=60&type=webp)
All-Time Academic All-Americans
| Name | Sport | Team | Year |
| Darren Brady | Basketball | First Team | 1985 |
| Christa Champion | Basketball | First Team | 1984, 1985, 1986 |
| Patrick Conroy | Football | First Team | 2011 |
| John Cuozzo | Football | First Team | 1987 |
| *Darren Eales | Soccer | First Team | 1995 |
| Marty Edwards | Football | First Team | 1986 |
| Dave Folsom | Football | First Team | 1982 |
| *Chris Fox | Soccer | First Team | 1996 |
| *Katie Goddard | Gymnastics | First Team | 2012 |
| *Phil Goss | Lacrosse | First Team | 2019, 2020 |
| Nick Hartigan | Football | First Team | 2005 |
| ^Nick Hartigan | Football | First Team | 2006 |
| Travis Holcombe | Football | First Team | 1981 |
| *Dylan Molloy | Lacrosse | First Team | 2017 |
| Todd Murray | Basketball | First Team | 1985 |
| *Karen Prazar | Crew | First Team | 2004 |
| *Daniel Ricketts | Swimming | First Team | 2009 |
| Katy Schmidt | Soccer | First Team | 2017 |
| Scott Simpson | Baseball | First Team | 1987 |
| Matthew Sullivan | Basketball | First Team | 2013 |
| *Peter Tarwid | Tennis | First Team | 2018 |
| Jim Turner | Basketball | First Team | 1986 |
| *Katie Auriemma | Field Hockey | Second Team | 2008 |
| *Suzanne Bailey | Soccer/Lacrosse | Second Team | 1991 |
| Arnie Berman | Basketball | Second Team | 1972 |
| *Yann Danis | Ice Hockey | Second Team | 2004 |
| J.J. Eno | Baseball | Second Team | 2007 |
| Paul Fichiera | Football | Second Team | 1996 |
| Bob Forster | Football | Second Team | 1978 |
| *Margaret Gardel | Crew | Second Team | 1998 |
| Ryan Graddy | Track & Field | Second Team | 2008 |
| Sam Grigo | Baseball | Second Team | 2017 |
| Zach Hunsaker | Basketball | Second Team | 2019 |
| Paul Jasinowski | Football | Second Team | 2009 |
| *Larken Kemp | Lacrosse | Second Team | 2017 |
| Mike Konieczny | Baseball | Second Team | 1977 |
| Garrett Leffellman | Basketball | Second Team | 2011 |
| Rick Lloyd | Basketball | Second Team | 1992 |
| Joe Lomuscio | Baseball | Second Team | 2019 |
| Dan Lowry | Track & Field | Second Team | 2012 |
| *Oliver Marti | Lacrosse | Second Team | 1993 |
| *Ruby Moore-Bloom | Crew | Second Team | 2017 |
| Scott Nelson | Football | Second Team | 1976 |
| Ellen Newberry | Softball | Second Team | 1985 |
| *Kelly O'Hear | Skiing | Second Team | 2007 |
| John Plansky | Baseball | Second Team | 1987 |
| Paul Raymond | Football | Second Team | 2007, 2008 |
| Conor Reardon | Baseball | Second Team | 2008 |
| Ben Rosenblatt | Football | Second Team | 2017 |
| *Kate Saul | Crew | Second Team | 2000 |
| Brian Sennett | Baseball | Second Team | 1983 |
| Dylan Sheehan | Soccer | Second Team | 2008 |
| Matt Simmons | Football | Second Team | 1997 |
| *Amy Tarczynski | Crew | Second Team | 2019 |
| Jeff Trauger | Football | Second Team | 1983 |
| *Krystyn Van Vliet | Crew | Second Team | 1998 |
| *Zoe Verni | Lacrosse | Second Team | 2019 |
| *Hans Wittusen | Soccer | Second Team | 1997 |
| Donna Yaffe | Basketball | Second Team | 1984 |
| Adom Crew | Soccer | Third Team | 2004 |
| Lindsay Cunningham | Soccer | Third Team | 2008 |
| J.J. Eno | Baseball | Third Team | 2008 |
| Naja Ferjan | Track & Field | Third Team | 2006 |
| *Rachel Gottlieb | Crew | Third Team | 2015 |
| *Casey Kelsey | Crew | Third Team | 2011 |
| Sam Kernan-Schloss | Soccer | Third Team | 2012 |
| Rick Lloyd | Basketball | Third Team | 1991 |
| Joe Lomuscio | Baseball | Third Team | 2020 |
| *Dylan Molloy | Lacrosse | Third Team | 2016 |
| Michelle Moses | Softball | Third Team | 2008, 2009 |
| Matt Mullery | Basketball | Third Team | 2010 |
| *Jeff Nord | Track & Field | Third Team | 1999 |
| Will Quigley | Football | Third Team | 2015 |
| Dylan Remick | Soccer | Third Team | 2012 |
| *Muriel Solberg | Crew | Third Team | 2016 |
| Steven Spieth | Basketball | Third Team | 2017 |
| *Coley Sullivan | Swimming | First Team | 2020 |
| *Coley Sullivan | Swimming | Third Team | 2019 |
| Matthew Sullivan | Basketball | Third Team | 2012 |
| Sheila Terranova | Field Hockey | Third Team | 1985 |
| *Ed Watts | Track & Field | Third Team | 1997 |
| *Luke Weiser | Water Polo | Third Team | 2017 |
| *Andy Wiener | Water Polo | Third Team | 2006 |
| Donna Yaffe | Basketball | Third Team | 1985 |
| Sue Beauliue | Softball | Honorable Mention | 1986 |
| *Lauren Becker | Lacrosse | Honorable Mention | 1986 |
| *Gretchen Orr | Soccer | Honorable Mention | 1985 |
| John Plansky | Baseball | Honorable Mention | 1986 |
| Donna Yaffe | Basketball | Honorable Mention | 1983 |
Those indicated by an asterisk (*) were on the at-large team
Those indicated by (^) were the Academic All-American of the Year
