June 10, 2004 Three members of the Brown University baseball team took part in the 2004 New England All-Star Game played at Fenway Park in Boston, MA. Juniors Jeff Nichols and Bobby Wiginton along with sophomore Paul Christian were selected to compete in the annual game. The College Division All-Stars knocked off the University All-Stars, 9-6, despite some hot hitting by the Bears trio as the three each recorded a hit. Christian was a First Team All-New England selection, while Wiginton and Nichols were Second Team All-New England honorees.

A First Team All-Ivy selection, Christian led the Bears with 11 homeruns, second in the league, while batting .349 on the season. He had two multi-homerun games, including a grand slam. Christian also finished second in the league with 47 runs scored and went errorless in 73 chances in right field. Christian batted .347 in the Ancient Eight and recorded six RBI in a win over Columbia.

Wiginton, who was also a First Team All-Ivy selection, recently earned CoSIDA District I Academic All-American honors. The left fielder led Brown and was second in the Ivy League with a .415 overall and .437 league batting average. Wiginton averaged an astonishing .667 with the bases loaded, and also averaged .542 with runners on base, both coming in conference play. He put together a pair of 10-game hitting streaks during the season, and compiled 14 multi-hit games, including four hits on two occasions.

A Second Team All-Ivy choice, Nichols finished the year red-hot at the plate, batting over .420 in the Bears' last 10 games of the season. A shortstop, he finished with a .342 average with 32 RBI in all games, fourth on the team. In Ivy League play, Nichols batted .391, sixth in the league, with 16 RBI and 24 runs scored, third best in the Ivies. Nichols' 53 total bases in conference play led the league.