Presented in memory of Kate Silver ’86 to the outstanding first-year varsity female athlete.
| Name | Sport | Year |
| Sue Cutler | Squash | 1985 |
| Karen Dieffenthaller | Swimming | 1986 |
| Darci Lamphere | Swimming | 1987 |
| Teri Smith | Track & Field |
1988 |
| Anna Sloan | Tennis | 1989 |
| Christy Trexler | Softball | 1990 |
| Michelle Pagliaro | Basketball | 1991 |
| Martina Jerant | Basketball | 1992 |
| Kerri Whitaker | Field Hockey/Lacrosse | 1993 |
| Katie King | Ice Hockey/Softball | 1994 |
| Shannon Feaster | Squash | 1995 |
| Devon Kennedy | Squash | 1996 |
| Megan Reha | Swimming | 1996 |
| Tara Mounsey | Ice Hockey/Field Hockey | 1997 |
| Jenn Lears | Swimming | 1998 |
| Elizabeth DiBona | Skiing | 1999 |
| Barbara Maloni | Basketball | 2000 |
| Elizabeth Carpenter | Golf | 2001 |
| Jessica Link | Ice Hockey | 2002 |
| Kim Singer | Tennis | 2003 |
| Kathryn Moos | Soccer/Ice Hockey | 2004 |
| Sarah Groothuis | Track & Field |
2005 |
| Brittany Anderson | Gymnastics | 2006 |
| Alicia Sacramone | Gymnastics | 2007 |
| Bianca Aboubakare | Tennis | 2008 |
| Cassandra Herzberg |
Tennis |
2009 |
| Misia Krasowski | Tennis | 2010 |
| Louise Breen | Crew | 2011 |
| Lauren Waterbury | Track & Field | 2012 |
| Kebbeh Darpolor | Track & Field | 2013 |
| Logan Harris | Crew | 2013 |
| Dayna Lord | Tennis | 2014 |
| Josie Natrasevschi | Track & Field | 2015 |
| Shayna Mehta | Basketball | 2016 |
| Justine Gaziano | Basketball | 2017 |
Updated as of May 22, 2017